Table 1

Patient characteristics at baseline for groups receiving SMT vs groups receiving recommended interventions (s = 12; n = 2475).

Demographic data SMT Recommended interventions
Age, mean (SD) years (s = 11, n = 2409) 47 (14) 47 (14)
Sex, n (%) female (s = 11, n = 2412) 667 (57) 684 (55)
Body mass index, mean (SD) (s = 8, n = 1434) 27 (5) 27 (5)
Ethnicity, n (%) white (s = 5, n = 861) 409 (91) 388 (88)
Lifestyle factors
Physical activity, (%) (s = 6, n = 824)
Low (1 or less than once a week) 115 (32) 166 (36)
Medium (2–3× a week) 146 (40) 166 (36)
High (more than 3×a week) 100 (28) 131 (28)
Smoking, n (%) non-smokers (s = 6, n = 1173) 451 (80) 453 (75)
Alcohol use, n (%) * *
Socio-demographics
Marital status, n (%) married; living with a partner (s = 6, n = 1173) 397 (69) 404 (68)
Level of education, n (%) low/middle (s = 7, n = 1672) 600 (68) 534 (68)
Income, n (%) * *
Employment status, n (%) at work (s = 9, n = 2126) 818 (78) 770 (72)
Nature and severity of LBP
Duration of LBP, n (%) less than 12 months (s = 7, n = 1252) 121 (20) 149 (23)
Leg pain, n (%) (s = 5, n = 1038) 320 (59) 281 (57)
Previous LBP treatment received, n (%) (s = 5, n = 930) 258 (28) 218 (23)
Previous physiotherapy for low back pain received, n (%) (s = 5, n = 771) 64 (8) 72 (9)
Previous SMT for low back pain received, n (%) (s = 6, n = 988) 209 (21) 111 (11)
Used medication for low back, n (%) (s = 6, n = 1018) 200 (20) 269 (26)
Non-specific, n (%) * *
Comorbidities * *
Type of treatment * *
Psychosocial factors SMT Control
Depression, n (%) (s = 5, n = 1297) 43 (6) 75 (13)
Treatment preference/expectations * *
Primary outcomes
Pain
Combined pain score at baseline, mean (SD), (s = 12, n = 2441) 49.5 (22.3) 49.8 (21.6)
Combined pain score at one month, mean (SD), (s = 10, n = 1948) 34.2 (23.0) 35.8 (23.9)
Combined pain score at three months, mean (SD), (s = 9, n = 1673) 27.92 (23.0) 32.1 (24.3)
Combined pain score at six months, mean (SD), (s = 8, n = 1321) 27.35 (23.1) 32.3 (23.9)
Combined pain score at twelve months, mean (SD), (s = 10, n = 1816) 31.80 (26.8) 33.3 (25.4)
Functional status
RMDQ sum score at baseline, mean (SD), (s = 9, n = 2174) 9.0 (5.0) 10.1 (5.4)
RMDQ sum score at one month, mean (SD), (s = 8, n = 1760) 5.6 (5.0) 6.7 (5.4)
RMDQ sum score at three months, mean (SD), (s = 8, n = 1648) 4.8 (5.1) 5.5 (5.3)
RMDQ sum score at six months, mean (SD), (s = 8, n = 1348) 5.0 (5.4) 6.3 (6.0)
RMDQ sum score at twelve months, mean (SD), (s = 7, n = 1575) 5.4 (5.7) 6.2 (5.92)
Secondary outcomes
SF36 Physical Component Scale of SF36 at baseline, mean (SD), (s = 5, n = 1362) 40.7 (7.2) 41.1 (7.6)
SF36 Physical Component Scale of SF36 at one month, mean (SD), (s = 3, n = 865) 44.1 (7.9) 45.7 (8.1)
SF36 Physical Component Scale of SF36 at three months weeks, mean (SD), (s = 4, n = 1154) 46.7 (8.2) 46.9 (8.5)
SF36 Physical Component Scale of SF36 at six months, mean (SD), (s = 5, n = 839) 47.3 (7.8) 47.9 (7.7)
SF36 Physical Component Scale of SF36 at twelve months, mean (SD), (s = 5, n = 1249) 46.4 (8.6) 46.8 (8.8)
SF36 Mental Component Scale of SF36 at baseline, mean (SD), (s = 5, n = 1362) 43.8 (9.1) 45.1 (9.6)
SF36 Mental Component Scale of SF36 at one month, mean (SD), (s = 3, n = 865) 45.5 (8.8) 46.9 (8.8)
SF36 Mental Component Scale of SF36 at three months, mean (SD), (s = 4, n = 1154) 46.9 (9.0) 47.3 (9.5)
SF36 Mental Component Scale of SF36 at six months, mean (SD), (s = 5, n = 839) 46.9 (9.1) 48.0 (8.9)
SF36 Mental Component Scale of SF36 at twelve months, mean (SD), (s = 5, n = 1249) 45.7 (8.9) 46.2 (10.0)
Medication use at baseline, n (% medication use) (s = 3, n = 668) 145 (22) 216 (32)
Medication use at one month, n (% medication use) (s = 3, n = 646) 84 (13) 146 (23)
Medication use at three months, n (% medication use) (s = 3, n = 626) 78 (13) 132 (21)
Medication use at six months, n (% medication use) s = 3, n = 593) 67 (11) 143 (24)
Medication use at twelve months weeks, n (% medication use) (s = 3, n = 582) 82 (14) 141 (24)

SD = standard deviation; s = number of studies; n = number of participants; * combining categories was not meaningful or no data available.