Dietary Supplement Recommendations
By Saskatchewan Chiropractors:
Results Of An Online SurveyThis section is compiled by Frank M. Painter, D.C.
Send all comments or additions to: Frankp@chiro.org
FROM: Chiropractic & Manual Therapies 2013 (Mar 7); 21 (1): 11 ~ FULL TEXT
Kent Stuber, Paul Bruno, Kevyn Kristmanson and Zara Ali
6100 Leslie Street,
Toronto, ON M2H 3J1, Canada.
kstuber@cmcc.caBACKGROUND: Chiropractors receive training in nutrition during their education, previous surveys have found that chiropractors frequently provide recommendations to patients relating to nutrition and dietary supplement intake. However, it has not been ascertained which specific supplements chiropractors recommend or the types of health conditions for which supplement recommendations are made.
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to determine which dietary supplements are most commonly recommended by chiropractors in the province of Saskatchewan,Canada and the health conditions for which supplement recommendations are made.
DESIGN: An online survey of licensed chiropractors practicing in the province of Saskatchewan, Canada was distributed three times following online and in-person notifications of the survey.
STATISTICAL ANALYSES PERFORMED: Descriptive statistics were reported, predominantly in the form of means and proportions.
RESULTS: response rate of 45% was obtained. All of the respondents (100%) indicated providing nutritional advice or counselling to patients, while nearly all (99%) indicated providing dietary supplement recommendations to patients. Respondents estimated that they provide nutritional advice or counselling to 31% of their patients on average, and recommend dietary supplements to an average of 25% of their patients.
The most commonly recommended supplements were glucosamine sulfate, multivitamins, vitamin C, vitamin D, calcium, omega-3 fatty acids, and probiotics. The most common reasons to recommend dietary supplements were for“general health and wellness” (82% of respondents),
“bone health” (74%),
“rheumatologic, arthritic, degenerative, or inflammatory conditions” (72%), and
“acute and/or chronic musculoskeletal conditions” (65%) .CONCLUSION: The majority of respondents indicated providing nutritional counselling and recommendations for dietary supplements to their patients. Respondents generally recommend a small number of dietary supplements and provide these recommendations and counselling to fewer than half of their patients on average, while tending to focus on conditions most closely related to the scope of practice of chiropractors. The findings of this study may have been limited by selection bias owing to the low response rate and as those who respond to surveys are often more likely to respond positively.
From the FULL TEXT Article:
Background
Use of dietary supplements is quite common throughout North America, with surveys indicating a past year usage prevalence of up to 73% in the general public [1]. The most commonly utilized supplements are multivitamins/multi-minerals, followed by single vitamin or mineral supplements; other supplements (e.g. herbal/botanical) are less commonly utilized [1]. In this manuscript we will define dietary supplements as encompassing both herbal supplements (i.e. those obtained from a botanical source) and nutritional supplements (e.g. vitamin and/or mineral formulations, amino acids, and hormones not derived from a botanical source) [2].
Chiropractors are among the numerous health care professionals who provide nutritional and dietary advice to patients. In the typical North American chiropractic educational program students complete two courses in nutrition, one providing the foundations of biochemistry and nutrition, followed by a clinical nutrition course [3,4]. Some chiropractors will continue to additional specialization in nutrition, obtaining post-graduate certificates, graduate degrees, or diplomate status in clinical nutrition [3,4].
A 2009 survey of chiropractors across the United States indicated that approximately 94% make nutritional or dietary recommendations to patients [5]. This is higher than previous surveys of American chiropractors which have typically shown 80% of chiropractors incorporate nutritional counselling in their practices [4,6]. A 2001 survey [6] indicated that the most commonly recommended nutritional products by chiropractors were vitamins (by 78% of chiropractors), followed by minerals (65%), herbal preparations (54%), and nutrient combinations for specific conditions (54%). Previous surveys of registered dietitians indicate that 74% to 97% recommend dietary supplements, while only 13% recommend herbal-based supplements [7,8]. This is compared with 40% of pharmacists [2], 79% of physicians [9], 82% of nurses [9], 72% of cardiologists, 66% of dermatologists, and 91% of orthopedists who have indicated recommending dietary supplements to patients [10].
We conducted an online survey, the primary purpose of which was to determine which dietary supplements are most commonly recommended by chiropractors in the province of Saskatchewan, Canada. The current survey is unique compared with previous surveys of chiropractors on this topic in that it asked the frequency with which chiropractors recommend numerous specific dietary supplements and the health conditions for which they recommend supplements, in addition to inquiring about professional behaviours and post-graduate training related to nutrition.
Methods
This study consisted of an online survey conducted in September 2012. The inclusion criteria consisted of all chiropractors who were actively practicing in the province of Saskatchewan and members of the Chiropractors’ Association of Saskatchewan (CAS). The CAS distributed the e-mail messages for the authors so that confidentiality of their members’ contact information was not violated. All qualified participants were contacted up to a total of five times, including four e-mail messages and one in-person invitation. Participants were initially contacted by a pre-notification e-mail message. Five days later, two of the authors (PB and KK) attended the CAS Annual General Meeting and announced that the initial e-mail invitation would be distributed two days after the meeting (seven days after the pre-notification message). Subsequently, two reminder e-mail invitations were distributed at further two week intervals (14 and 28 days after the initial e-mail invitation message).
The survey e-mail invitation and reminder messages contained the objective and purpose of the study (as part of a study information sheet), which then linked interested participants to an informed consent form via one of the authors’ (KS) Survey Monkey™ account. Participants who agreed to be involved in the study and agreed to the terms of the informed consent were asked to click on an “I Agree” button, which then directed them to the rest of the survey. The survey consisted of several questions including those related to: demographic and nutrition educational background, professional behaviours related to nutrition, how often they recommend different dietary supplements, and the types of conditions for which they recommend supplements (see Additional file 1). Respondents answered the survey in complete anonymity. There was no compensation for participation in this survey. Survey results were summarized with descriptive statistics, expressed as either means or proportions of respondents, depending on the question’s structure. Ethics approval was received from the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College Research Ethics Board.
Additional file 1. Online Nutritional Survey
Prior to commencement of the survey study, a convenience sample of three clinicians at the HK Lee Clinic on the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College campus were asked to review and complete the questionnaire to ensure appropriate question quality, style, and content and to allow for revisions to be made. Minor changes were made to survey questions based on the feedback, producing the final survey that was accessed by respondents. The data provided by the clinicians is not included in the data reported herein.
Results
Table 1 Of the 182 active CAS members who were contacted, 81 participated in the survey (45% response rate). Demographic information for the survey respondents and for all chiropractors registered with the CAS at the time the survey was conducted are presented in Table 1. With regards to these demographic data, the survey respondents appear to be representative of the target population of chiropractors.
The respondents indicated varying levels of continuing education course involvement related to nutrition and dietary supplements: 17% had not completed any such courses, 54% had taken between one and five courses, 12% had taken between six and ten courses, and 16% had taken 11 or more courses. The vast majority (94%) did not have or were not in the process of completing a post-graduate certificate, fellowship, diplomate, or Master’s degree in nutrition, while 5% had a post-graduate certificate in nutrition, and 2.5% had a post-graduate fellowship or diplomate in nutrition (one of the respondents had both a post-graduate certificate and fellowship or diplomate).
All of the respondents (100%) indicated providing nutritional advice or counselling to patients, while nearly all (99%) also indicated providing dietary supplement recommendations to patients. On average, the respondents estimated that they provide nutritional advice or counselling to 31% of their patients, and recommend dietary supplements to 25% of their patients. In addition, respondents estimated that they refer an average of 6% of their patients to medical doctors and 11% of their patients to naturopathic doctors for dietary or nutrition-related concerns. The average estimated percentage of patients referred to registered dieticians, nutritionists, and homeopathic doctors was 3% (each).
Table 2 Table 2 depicts the number of respondents who indicated recommending different dietary supplements to their patients, as well as the number of respondents who sell those supplements in their clinics. The supplements that were recommended most often (i.e. recommended “almost always or all of the time” or “often” by =25% of respondents) were glucosamine sulfate, multi-vitamins, vitamin C, vitamin D, calcium, omega-3 fatty acids, and probiotics.
When asked for the types of conditions or reasons for which they recommend dietary supplements, the most common response was for “general health and wellness” (82% of respondents), followed by “bone health” (74%), “rheumatologic, arthritic, degenerative, or inflammatory conditions’ (72%), “acute and/or chronic musculoskeletal conditions” (65%), “weight loss or management” (36%), “digestive conditions” (35%), “neurologic conditions” (35%), “reproductive conditions such as menopause or premenstrual symptoms management” (27%), and “skin conditions” (25%). The remaining reasons for recommending dietary supplements were indicated by fewer than 25% of the respondents and included “anti-aging” (22%), “hormone imbalances” (20%), “cardiovascular conditions” (17%), “nutritional cleansing or colon health” (16%), “weight gain” (15%), “endocrine conditions” (14%), and “psychological conditions” (10%).
Discussion
All of the respondents to this survey indicated that they provide nutritional advice or counselling to patients, and 99% provide dietary supplement recommendations. Similarly, a 2009 survey of 2371 chiropractors across the United States indicated that 94% provided nutritional and dietary recommendations [5]. In a survey of 125 New York chiropractors, Holtzman and Burke found that 80% of respondents utilized nutritional counseling in their practices, and dietary supplement prescription was the most common form of such counselling [4]. Respondents were asked to estimate the percentage of their patients to whom nutritional advice or counselling was provided (31% on average) as well as the percentage of patients who received dietary supplement recommendations (25% on average). These rates are lower than those reported by 74 American chiropractors in a 2001 survey, who provided nutritional counselling to an average of 37% of their patients, and recommended dietary supplements to an average of 50% of their patients [6].
Although dietary supplement recommendation to patients appears to be common amongst Saskatchewan chiropractors, only a small number of dietary supplements are frequently recommended (glucosamine sulfate, multi-vitamins, vitamin C, vitamin D, calcium, omega-3 fatty acids, and probiotics). These results are not substantially different from the findings of Hetherwick et al. that the most commonly recommended nutrient-based dietary supplements by California dietitians were calcium, multi-vitamins with or without minerals, vitamin E, vitamin C, and iron [7]. Their most commonly recommended herbal supplement was Echinacea, a finding supported by Cashman et al. in their survey of Massachusetts dietitians [7,11]. Conversely, nearly half of the current survey respondents indicated that they “rarely” or “never” recommend Echinacea. Interestingly, a recent review indicates that Echinacea may be effective in reducing the duration and severity of a cold [12].
When considering the types of health conditions for which respondents recommend dietary supplements, there was a level of concurrence with the specific supplements being recommended. The most common reason for recommending supplements to patients was for “general health and wellness” (by 82% of respondents), which is reflected by multi-vitamins, vitamin C, and probiotics being among the most recommended supplements. Vitamin C has been found effective in preventing the common cold [12], however there is conflicting and insufficient evidence to date regarding the use of multivitamins [13-15] and probiotics [16,17] for the prevention and treatment of different health conditions. The next most common reason to recommend supplements was for “bone health” (74%), which is reflected by vitamin D and calcium being frequently recommended and well supported in the literature and by clinical practice guidelines [18-20]. Omega-3 fatty acids and glucosamine sulfate were also commonly recommended by respondents, and this may be a reflection of their frequently recommending supplements for “rheumatologic, arthritic, degenerative, or inflammatory conditions” (72%) and “acute and/or chronic musculoskeletal conditions” (65%). However, there is conflicting evidence surrounding the use of both omega-3 fatty acids [21-24] and glucosamine sulfate [25-27] for such conditions. Holtzman and Burke found that the most common conditions for which New York chiropractors provided nutritional counselling were osteoarthritis (by 76% of respondents) and osteoporosis (71%), followed by obesity, diabetes, coronary artery disease, fibromyalgia, and allergies (each at least 50%) [4].
In comparing the current results to other health professions, a recent survey of American dietitians found that the most common reason for recommending supplements by this group was bone health (70%), followed by filling nutrition gaps (69%), overall health and wellness (49%), lowering cholesterol (46%), cardiac health (46%), dietary pattern reasons (for vegetarians or vegans for example, 43%), and digestive health (39%) [8]. Dickinson et al. surveyed 900 physicians (including 300 general practitioners) and 277 nurses, and the three most common reasons these groups recommend dietary supplements to patients were for overall health and wellness (41% of physicians and 62% of nurses), followed by bone health (41% and 58%, respectively) and joint health (37% and 37%) [9]. In a survey of 300 cardiologists, 300 dermatologists, and 300 orthopedists, the most common reasons that each group provided for recommending dietary supplements was reflected in their professional specialty [10]. For example, the cardiologists’ most common reason for recommending dietary supplements was to lower cholesterol (58%), followed by heart health (55%) and maintaining healthy cholesterol (36%) [10]. Dermatologists most frequently recommended dietary supplements for skin, hair, and nails (81%), followed by overall health and wellness (30%) and bone health (25%). Orthopedists most frequently recommended dietary supplements for bone health (75%), followed by joint health (73%) and musculoskeletal pain (53%) [10]. The findings from the current survey reflect the trends observed in these surveys in that “general health and wellness” was the most commonly cited reason for Saskatchewan chiropractors to recommend supplements to patients, followed by “bone health”, “rheumatologic, arthritic, degenerative, or inflammatory conditions”, and “acute and/or chronic musculoskeletal conditions.” It is reasonable to expect chiropractors’ recommendations to parallel those of orthopedists as both groups predominantly treat patients with musculoskeletal and degenerative conditions, and this does appear to be the case. However, chiropractors seem to have a substantially greater tendency to recommend supplements for “general health and wellness” than do orthopedists (82% versus 25%) [10].
Postgraduate education in nutrition
Smith and Spillman found that their chiropractor respondents had completed 84 postgraduate nutrition hours on average [6], while the majority of respondents to the current survey had taken between one and five postgraduate courses on nutrition and 28% had completed at least six postgraduate nutrition courses. A small minority of respondents (6%) had completed formal postgraduate qualification (certificate, fellowship, diplomate, graduate degree) in nutrition. Holtzman and Burke [4] found that 65% of their chiropractor respondents did not feel that they had received adequate education in nutrition, and 47% of the respondents in Smith and Spillman [6] felt similarly. Although the current survey’s respondents were not asked to rate the perceived adequacy of the nutritional education in their chiropractic training, these previous survey findings may in part explain why so many respondents have augmented their education with postgraduate training in nutrition.
Referral rates to and from other health professionals
A 2009 survey of chiropractors in the United States indicated that chiropractors refer patients to nutritionists and receive patient referrals from nutritionists at a frequency between “Never” and “Rarely” (<1/month), while patient referrals to and from family practitioners occurred at a frequency between “Rarely” and “Sometimes” (1-3/month) [28]. The findings from the current survey are in line with these, as respondents indicated referring a higher percentage of their patients to medical doctors (6% of their patients on average) and naturopathic doctors (11%) for dietary or nutrition-related concerns than to dietitians or nutritionists (3% each).
Study strengths and weaknesses
The response rate of this survey was 45%, which is low, but still within the anticipated range for surveys of chiropractors [29]. Previous surveys of chiropractors regarding nutritional and dietary supplement recommendations have obtained response rates varying between 13% and 34%. The current study actually had the highest response rate of chiropractors thus far on this topic, making it difficult to necessarily validate the results of the current survey against those conducted previously [4-6]. Numerous steps were taken to encourage a higher response rate, such as pre-notification, and multiple contacts, both in person and through e-mail messages [29]. Respondents to this survey were practicing chiropractors from only one jurisdiction in Canada, which limits the ability to generalize results to other North American jurisdictions. Additionally, not all of respondents answered all of the survey questions, creating a level of uncertainty for those particular results.
Furthermore, while this survey did inquire about different reasons for respondents to recommend dietary supplements, it did not ask respondents to directly relate these reasons to specific supplements. Additionally, the list of supplements occasionally did not necessarily correspond to those different reasons. For example, none of the listed supplements would be considered to be specifically targeted towards “weight loss or management”, which was mentioned as a reason for recommending supplements by 36% of respondents. In addition, all of the survey respondents indicated providing nutritional advice or counselling to patients, and nearly all respondents provide dietary supplement recommendations to patients. These data lead to a concern of some degree of selection bias where only those who do recommend supplements or provide nutritional advice or counselling chose to complete the survey. As mentioned previously Table 1 indicates that the survey respondents do not appear to be essentially different from the entire population of Saskatchewan chiropractors from a demographic standpoint, thus it is unclear if there is any bias in the results due to non-response.
Conclusions
The majority of respondents to this survey indicated providing nutritional counselling and recommendations for dietary supplements to patients. They provide these recommendations and counselling to fewer than half of their patients on average and tend to focus on conditions most related to the chiropractic scope of practice, including general health and wellness, along with musculoskeletal and degenerative conditions. Respondents mainly recommend a small number of dietary supplements such as multivitamins, vitamin C, vitamin D, calcium, probiotics, glucosamine sulfate, and omega-3 fatty acids. Most of the responding chiropractors have completed postgraduate courses on nutrition, and generally do not refer a high proportion of patients for nutritional counselling to other health professionals. Future research should be directed towards larger jurisdictions which may be more representative of North American chiropractors and should include qualitative research which elucidates the reasons for different professional behaviours relating to nutrition.
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors’ contributions
KS conceived and designed the study, participated in data collection and analysis, and drafted the manuscript. PB contributed to study design, data collection, data analysis, and revisions of the manuscript. KK contributed to study design, data collection, and revisions of the manuscript. ZA contributed to study design and revisions of the manuscript. All of the authors have given their approval of the final version to be published.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to acknowledge the Board members and administrative staff of the Chiropractors’ Association of Saskatchewan (CAS) for their assistance with survey invitation distribution to members of the CAS.References:
Timbo BB, Ross MP, McCarthy PV, Lin C-TJ:
Dietary supplements in a national survey: prevalence of use and reports of adverse events.
J Am Diet Assoc 2006, 106:1966-1974
Howard N, Tsourounis C, Kapusnik-uner J:
Dietary supplement survey of pharmacists: personal and professional practices.
J Altern Complement Med 2001, 7:667-680
Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Hyland JK:
Chapter 1 - the chiropractic profession. In Practice analysis of chiropractic 2010.
Edited by Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Hyland JK. Greeley:
National Board of Chiropractic Examiners; 2009:1-12
Holtzman D, Burke J:
Nutritional counseling in the chiropractic practice: a survey of New York practitioners.
Journal of Chiropractic Medicine 2007, 6:27-31
Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Hyland JK:
Chapter 9 - professional functions and treatment procedures.
In Practice analysis of chiropractic 2010.
Edited by Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Hyland JK. Greeley:
National Board of Chiropractic Examiners; 2009:121-136
Smith D, Spillman D:
A survey of chiropractors ’ use of nutrition in private practice.
Journal of Chiropractic Humanities 2001, 10:1-6
Hetherwick C, Morris MN, Silliman K:
Perceived knowledge, attitudes, and practices of California registered dietitians regarding dietary supplements.
J Am Diet Assoc 2006, 106:438-442
Dickinson A, Bonci L, Boyon N, Franco JC:
Dietitians use and recommend dietary supplements: report of a survey.
Nutr J 2012, 11:14
Dickinson A, Boyon N, Shao A:
Physicians and nurses use and recommend dietary supplements: report of a survey.
Nutr J 2009, 8:29
Dickinson A, Shao A, Boyon N, Franco JC:
Use of dietary supplements by cardiologists, dermatologists and orthopedists: report of a survey.
Nutr J 2011, 10:20
Cashman LS, Burns JT, Otieno IM, Fung T:
Massachusetts registered Dietitians’ knowledge, attitudes, opinions, personal Use, and recommendations to clients about herbal supplements.
J Altern Complement Med 2003, 9:735-746
Nahas R, Balla A:
Complementary and alternative medicine for prevention and treatment of the common cold.
Canadian Family Physician 2011, 57:31-36
Frank E, Bendich A, Denniston M:
Use of vitamin-mineral supplements by female physicians in the United States.
Am J Clin Nutr 2000, 72:969-975
Greenwald P, Anderson D, Nelson Sa, Taylor PR:
Clinical trials of vitamin and mineral supplements for cancer prevention.
Am J Clin Nutr 2007, 85:314S-317S
Stratton J, Godwin M:
The effect of supplemental vitamins and minerals on the development of prostate cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Fam Pract 2011, 28:243-252
Ritchie ML, Romanuk TN:
A meta-analysis of probiotic efficacy for gastrointestinal diseases.
PLoS One 2012, 7:e34938
Rowland I, Capurso L, Collins K, Cummings J, Delzenne N, Goulet O, Guarner F, Marteau P, Meier R:
Current level of consensus on probiotic science–report of an expert meeting–London, 23 November 2009.
Gut Microbes 2010, 1:436-439
Papaioannou A, Morin S, Cheung AM, Atkinson S, Brown JP, Feldman S, Hanley DA, Hodsman A, Jamal SA, Kaiser SM, Kvern B, Siminoski K, Leslie WD:
2010 clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis and management of osteoporosis in Canada: summary.
Can Med Assoc J 2010, 182:1864-1873
Eisman J, Ebeling P, Ewald D, Flicker L, Holborow B:
Clinical guideline for the prevention and treatment of osteoporosis in postmenopausal women and older men.
South Melbourne: Royal Australian College of General Practitioners; 2010:1-76
Stránský M, Rysavá L:
Nutrition as prevention and treatment of osteoporosis.
Physiol Res 2009, 58(Suppl 1):S7-S11
Calder PC:
Omega-3 fatty acids and inflammatory processes.
Nutrients 2010, 2:355-374
Wardhana , Surachmanto ES, Datau Ea:
The role of omega-3 fatty acids contained in olive oil on chronic inflammation.
Acta Medica Indonesian 2011, 43:138-143
March L, Barrett C, Gale F, Lassere M, McQuade J:
Clinical guideline for the diagnosis and management of early rheumatoid arthritis.
South Melbourne: Royal Australian College of General Practitioners; 2009:1-46
Myhrstad MCW, Retterstøl K, Telle-Hansen VH, Ottestad I, Halvorsen B, Holven KB, Ulven SM:
Effect of marine n-3 fatty acids on circulating inflammatory markers in healthy subjects and subjects with cardiovascular risk factors.
Inflamm Res 2011, 60:309-319
Brand C, Buchbinder R, Wluka A, Ruth D, McKenzie S, Jones K:
Guideline for the non-surgical management of hip and knee osteoarthritis.
South Melbourne: Royal Australian College of General Practitioners; 2009:1-68
Black C, Clar C, Henderson R, MacEachern C, McNamee P, Quayyum Z, Royle P, Thomas S:
The clinical effectiveness of glucosamine and chondroitin supplements in slowing or arresting progression of osteoarthritis of the knee: a systematic review and economic evaluation.
Health Technol Assess 2009, 13:1-148
Wandel S, Juni P, Tendal B, Nuesch E, Villiger PM, Welton NJ, Reichenbach S, Trelle S:
Effects of glucosamine, chondroitin, or placebo in patients with osteoarthritis of hip or knee: network meta-analysis.
BMJ 2010, 341:c4675-c4675
Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Hyland JK:
Chapter 7 - the chiropractic practitioner. In Practice analysis of chiropractic 2010.
Edited by Christensen MG, Kollasch MW, Hyland JK. Greeley:
National Board of Chiropractic Examiners; 2009:73-94
Russell M, Verhoef M, Injeyan H, McMorland DG:
Response rates for surveys of chiropractors.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther 2004, 27:43-48.
Return to the NUTRITION Section
Since4-29-2013
| Home Page | Visit Our Sponsors | Become a Sponsor |
Please read our DISCLAIMER |